A local Democrat official told to resign after abortion remarks leave parents irate

 A local Democrat official in Massachusetts is facing calls to step down after complaining about the cost of special education for children with disabilities who are not aborted. 

Michael Hugo, the chair of the Framingham Democratic Committee, made the remarks during a city council meeting when discussing a proclamation about access to abortion and crisis pregnancy centers in the city. He said crisis pregnancy centers could misdiagnose a defect in a baby in the womb, leading to them being born and becoming a strain on a school budget. He issued a public apology after 10 days of backlash from members of his own party and parents of special needs children. 

"I saw what Michael had said as a personal attack against my own children," said Sheryl Goldstein, the chair of the Framingham Disabilities Commission. "That my children who had special needs were not worth the expense in the school system." 

In his public apology letter, Hugo called his comments "offensive and hurtful." 

"I am writing to offer my most sincere and humble apology to members of the Framingham Democratic Committee, but more especially my fellow members of Framingham's disability family community, for comments that I made at the last City Council meeting which were offensive and hurtful," he wrote.  

He said members of the committee did not "see or review" his remarks despite being sent out the night before the meeting.  

"Our fear is that if an unqualified sonographer misdiagnoses a heart defect, an organ defect, spina bifida or an encephalopathic defect that becomes a very local issue because our school budget will have to absorb the cost of a child in special education, supplying lots and lots of special services to children, who were born with the defect," Hugo said at the Feb. 7 meeting. 

Laura Green, a disability advocate in Framingham told Fox News that she does not accept his apology. 

"I feel that it was generic and lackluster. I feel like after a statement like that is made, you can’t just pretend that it didn't happen or take it back because it's damaging to a community of people," she said. "The disability community is the only minority group that you can become a part of at any time."  

 

According to his LinkedIn, Hugo is also the director of policy and government affairs for the Massachusetts Association of Health Boards.  

Jon Fetherston, a special needs advocate and registered Republican said he was in disbelief when he heard the comments.  

"As a parent of an autistic child, I read those comments and go ‘what?’" he said. "A peer of mine thinks that I should’ve aborted my child because he was going to be a burden to a school budget?" 

Kristan Hawkins, the mother of two children with cystic fibrosis and the president of Students for Life told Fox News she was deeply offended by Hugo’s comments.  

"This is discrimination plain and simple," she said. "I think people who say that the sick cost too much for our society better find the fountain of youth real quick because someday that’s going to be them, it's going to be their family members." 

"This is eugenics, this is eugenics in 2023 America, this is an argument that sadly we’ve heard before and throughout American history, just regurgitated using a bunch of fancy lingo or support for abortion," Hawkins added. 

Laura Green says her best friend with down syndrome inspired her to be a disability advocate. (Laura Green) 

In his speech, Hugo said he was "speaking on behalf of the Framingham Democratic Committee," adding that it's their mission to "work for the common good by promoting racial, ethnic, social, and economic equality for the people of Framingham." 

"It’s astounding to see such a heartless statement, especially coming from 2023 America where we’re supposed to be this progressive inclusive society that celebrates diversity, come out and say ‘well yeah certain people shouldn’t be born because they're going to cost us too much money," Hawkins said. 

A speaker that came shortly after Hugo at the meeting denounced him and said he went "off the rails." 

"I’m a lifetime member of the Democratic Committee, and the person who wanted to represent us went off the rails on a different direction that was never brought before the Democratic Committee," said Pat Dunne, a former Framingham School Committee member, according to Framingham Source. "We’re not talking about eliminating special education students and the like. We’re talking about getting out good information to the people in Framingham. And he’s casting a bit too wide for me and that’s why I did want to say something." 

In a letter sent to city council members several hours before the meeting and obtained by Fox News, Hugo provided a preview of his remarks reported to the Source, asking if the state will "cover the medical costs for a fetus that had sound medical reason to be terminated." 

He questioned if the state would "cover the costs of special education for a down syndrome affected child" and "pay for the extraordinary medical expense of a child with an atrial septal defect?" 

"How much does Framingham’s Public School Department pay for unreimbursed special needs school transportation, specialized education and durable supplies?" he asked.  

Hugo also claimed crisis pregnancy centers' sonographers would likely misdiagnose defects "while proclaiming that it is a beautiful child living inside the mother and handing her an ultrasound photo that nobody can figure out without training, some diapers and a couple of ‘onesies’ for her new baby."  

Hugo said he and others are working to prevent pro-life crisis pregnancy centers from opening up in Framingham. 

Hawkins disputed Hugo’s complaints about crisis pregnancy centers. 

"Pregnancy care centers offer such excellent free services that even the abortion-supporting community has taken note," she said. "Preventing young mothers from getting free services is a sign that the abortion mindset has poisoned far too many in our culture."  

Goldstein added that due to her leadership position with the disabilities commission, she has received many calls and texts from families with special needs children in the community. 

"People are quite frankly very upset," she said "They want action." 

The Framingham Democratic Committee echoed Hugo’s apology in a statement issued last week, claiming his remarks did not reflect the full committee, adding "we fully disavow and denounce them." 

"If they disavow and do not support those comments, how do you leave him in charge of your organization?" Fetherston who has a child with autism asked. "He has an influential position inside the party and if he even thinks that, much less says it in a public meeting, then he shouldn’t be in a leadership position." 

"I think he should immediately step down," Fetherston added. 

Hawkins said that while she believes Hugo should be removed, his blunt comments "hopefully woke up a lot of people to their support of abortion." 

Neither Hugo nor the Framingham Democratic Committee responded to Fox News’ request for comment 

https://www.foxnews.com/politics/massachusetts-democrat-told-step-down-abortion-comments-leave-parents-irate?dicbo=v2-ixlljc3 

 

CIDP

Courtesy of my daughter

You never know what’s going to happen from one day to the next. Looking back to the winter of 2013, it’s clear my life has been divided between “before” and “after.”

Our family of seven (five daughters) had just moved to our new apartment on a yishuv outside of Yerushalayim. The morning after Chanukah vacation, my 14-year-old daughter, Ariella, woke up not feeling well. I was running around trying to get everyone out on time despite the back-to-school sluggishness and didn’t pay much attention to Ariella’s complaint. She didn’t seem that sick and I figured maybe she just needed another mental health day before going back to school.

Yet on day two, Ariella still hadn’t come down from her second-floor bedroom, claiming she felt too weak. And on day three I knew we needed a doctor and quickly. I made an appointment with our GP at the yishuv clinic. At this point Ariella literally could not stand up. We carried her to the car, but when we got out at the clinic, she fell to the ground, scraping her ankle very badly and bleeding heavily.

The staff tended to her ankle and then we had our appointment with our doctor. He had no clue what was going on, but decided he’d send her for blood work. There happened to be a visiting orthopedist at the clinic at that time so we consulted with him as well. He also was stymied, but didn’t think this was an orthopedic issue and thought we should head straight to the ER. We thought he was overacting, and decided to come back in the morning for the blood work and then make a decision based on that. But while the blood work showed nothing out of the ordinary, we had reached day five and it was clear something was very wrong.

We traveled to the hospital and were admitted to the ER. Ariella had to sit in a wheelchair; although she was able to shuffle her feet a bit to move a few feet, there was no way she could traverse the hospital corridors. My husband is a Kohein and avoids hospitals whenever possible, so it was me hauling her into the wheelchair — and she is taller than I am.

The ER staff took one look at her and began bombarding her with questions. Had she eaten anything different recently? Had she taken a vaccine recently? At one point they even sent me out of the room to ask her more personal things that perhaps she didn’t feel comfortable admitting with me around. They were afraid she was on drugs and wouldn’t admit it.

Finally, when the battery of tests and questions all showed nothing out of the ordinary, they admitted her to the pediatric ward and basically decided to wait and see what would happen next. What happened next was that things got worse.

Up until now the weakness Ariella was experiencing was mostly in her arms and legs. She couldn’t lift her arms to feed herself or brush her hair or take care of herself and her legs weren’t strong enough to hold her up. I was doing everything for her, lifting her, feeding her, helping her to the bathroom. It seemed we had hit rock bottom. But after a week of this, we realized rock bottom would get lower. Half of Ariella’s face became paralyzed.

I was petrified. The doctors were murmuring about the possibility of multiple sclerosis, but her symptoms didn’t really add up. Finally the doctors announced the diagnosis: Guillain-Barre Syndrome GBS (see sidebar).

That did seem to make sense. A GBS attack can happen suddenly, and symptoms can range from the inability to move one’s limbs, like Ariella, to paralysis affecting the pulmonary muscles, which can lead to intubation. The hospital did check Ariella’s breathing ability, and although it was a bit below normal, baruch Hashem it was sufficient.

The doctors proceeded to treat her for GBS, giving her IVIG treatments (an infusion of donated blood that contains healthy antibodies) intravenously. But it didn’t seem to make any difference. They also gave her a low dosage of steroids, also recommended treatment for GBS, but that, too, didn’t seem to fix the problem.

At this point we had been in the hospital for four weeks. Any sense of normal life had ground to a standstill. I work as a doula but had to cancel all my appointments, as I was spending all my time with Ariella in the hospital. My husband was trying to work and keep the rest of our family running. Our kehillah, rav, and neighbors rallied to help our family, but we were still at a loss.

As time passed, we began doubting the GBS diagnosis. While a GBS attack may be terribly debilitating, after the initial attack the patient begins to show improvement as the symptoms fade. However, in Ariella’s case, the symptoms were growing worse, not better. Still, the hospital stuck with its initial diagnosis. They decided to discharge us and send us to a pediatric rehab facility. We traveled by ambulance, not realizing this was going to be our home away from home for a long time.

Ariella’s schedule in rehab was daunting. She had therapy sessions from nine a.m. until four p.m. in all different areas: hydro, physical, occupational, emotional. The facility also scheduled family therapy and it was a lifesaver; we were reeling from the many changes the past month had wrought. Ariella was given a beautiful room with huge windows. As the weather warmed, we’d sit on the balcony of our room against a picturesque background of tall green pine trees and wispy white clouds. I felt that we had arrived at a good place and were ready to heal.

Ariella’s roommate was an Arab whose mother spoke no English or Hebrew. Yet our mutual circumstances forged a bond that surpassed politics. At one point I was at a low, feeling so despondent with our situation that I was breaking down. The Arab woman patted me on the back and pointed upward, a completely nonverbal communication, reminding me of where my help was really waiting.

Despite the many hours of therapy, Ariella still wasn’t making that much progress. At one point we were given an appointment with a famous pediatric neurologist who had a clinic in the hospital. He was a very experienced doctor, who was always surrounded by medical students as he pontificated on the various patients’ conditions.

We were called to his room where there were approximately ten medical students observing the consultation. The doctor told Ariella to stand up. She responded that she couldn’t. “Of course you can!” he said and proceeded to haul her up from her wheelchair. She immediately collapsed onto the floor. Nonplussed he turned to the students. “Classic GBS,” he declared. I was horrified.

That painful incident highlighted what we were realizing; no one was concerned with the discrepancies between the diagnosis of GBS and the progress Ariella wasn’t making.

Almost no one that is. Yamima, Ariella’s physical therapist, was originally from England and took a great interest in Ariella’s progress. It was she who questioned the GBS diagnosis and kept asking if we’d reconsidered the original diagnosis. In clear Hashgachah, she was also working with a different patient who had been admitted to the facility a short while before Ariella. This child had been diagnosed with CIDP (Chronic Inflammatory Demyelinating Polyneuropathy; see sidebar). Comparing the similarities between the two cases, Yamima persistently suggested to us that we pursue this diagnosis.

Things were coming to a head and although we agreed with Yamima’s points, still it seemed every major doctor out there was convinced Ariella had GBS. Yamima suggested we consult with another doctor, Professor Nevo, who worked in Hadassah Mt. Scopus.

We consulted with our rav and with a very big bikur cholim organization, and they were both concerned that Professor Nevo would not have time to review our case. The rav and the askan both suggested we see someone a bit lower down the totem pole who would take a more personal interest in our case. What we didn’t know was that Professor Nevo was the leading international pediatric expert on CIDP.

Despite Yamima’s insistence, we went ahead and booked an appointment with a different neurologist in Hadassah Mt. Scopus. Imagine our surprise when we arrived on the day of the appointment to find the doctor we expected, and Professor Nevo, both waiting for us in the room. The doctor said he’d asked Professor Nevo to sit in on the consult because it was clear that our case was complicated. And sure enough, about halfway through the intake, this doctor said he was bowing out, that this was way beyond his field, and he insisted Professor Nevo take over. Just like that, Ariella became the professor’s patient.

Sure enough, as he listened to our story, he was convinced that GBS was an incorrect diagnosis and that the accurate diagnosis was CIDP. CIDP is much rarer than GBS, and Ariella had to undergo many painful neurological tests to confirm this diagnosis. The testing took place over the course of two weeks and included such painful procedures as a nerve conduction test, which tested Ariella’s nerve endings with electric shocks to see how they’d respond; it was as horrific as it sounds. Since Ariella was so young, and these tests were so painful, most were done under some sort of anesthesia, which necessitated hospital stays and more pain.

To everyone’s surprise (except Professor Nevo’s), Ariella tested positive for CIDP. In addition to it being a rare condition, CIDP rarely affects a young teen like Ariella. But despite the odds, Ariella clearly had the condition.

Knowing the proper diagnosis and having the world’s pediatric expert on this condition on our team was a game changer. Professor Nevo prescribed higher than normally prescribed levels of steroids, which helped her recover. In the first few days of the steroids her face paralysis began to lift.

Yet the steroids came with serious side effects, with Ariella suffering from bloating and contending with mood swings. He also prescribed higher dosages of IVIG medication to prevent further attacks. The medication was given once a month in the hospital, intravenously, taking about 14 hours each time. The cost was exorbitant: 60,000 shekels per infusion. And at first our insurance refused the treatment. I went to battle, working my way higher and higher through insurance administration, until I reached the head offices in Tel Aviv. I insisted they give her the treatment, pointing out that if chas v’shalom Ariella had another attack, they’d be paying much more in the long run for her treatment and physical therapy. B’chasdei Hashem, they finally approved the treatment.

At that point, we were staying in the rehab facility throughout the week and coming home for Shabbos. My husband would carry Ariella up the stairs to our house, and she’d sleep on the main floor sofa over Shabbos, before heading back to rehab Sunday morning. I was spending all day with Ariella, but at night I had to go back to my other children. Yet Ariella literally couldn’t do anything for herself. One of the girls in her older sister’s class arranged a rotation of 11th and 12th graders who would each spend the night with Ariella, caring for her until I could come in the mornings. It was incredible what a difference this chesed made for us.

We had been in rehab for four months when Ariella was finally discharged to outpatient therapy, three times a week. The steroids were helping, and over that summer she was able to do more and more. Still, it took months to wean her off the steroids, a difficult process itself. Finally, at the end of that summer, Ariella was able to walk and even to climb stairs, albeit very slowly and with poor balance. She also attended Camp Simcha, enjoying herself for the first time in months.

Ariella had missed most of ninth grade, and now we had to make plans for the future. It was clear she would not be able to return to her high school in Yerushalayim, and we made arrangements to switch her to the local school on our yishuv. The municipality came through for us, first sending tutors to our house for homeschooling, and then later modifying the school building so Ariella would be able to attend, and providing her with bus service to and from school. It was wonderful that Ariella was able to return to a normal schedule but painful to know that all her hard work was in jeopardy, as she was susceptible to an attack at any time.

She managed to make it through a whole year before the next attack came. By now Professor Nevo was heading the neurology department in the famous Schneider Children’s hospital in Petach Tivkah, and so he had her hospitalized there under his auspices. He didn’t want to put her back on steroids and after it was clear that IVIG wasn’t working as effectively anymore, he instead prescribed a procedure called plasmapheresis. To describe this in layman’s terms, it’s basically like a blood rinse. Ariella would lie on a bed, with her blood and its treacherous attacking antibodies being emptied from her body via one arm, and in her other arm she would receive transfusions of healthy antibodies and new plasma. Thankfully, the procedure was helpful and we were discharged from the hospital, though she had to do it again every two months for a year, after which she was able to stop.

Ariella is still susceptible to attacks at any time, without any warning. We see Professor Nevo every three to six months. He’s developed a good kesher with Ariella, and the entire staff of Schneider greets her and cheers on her progress whenever she visits the hospital.

We try to pay back the kindness as well. At one point Professor Nevo asked us if he could feature Ariella at a convention of neurologists from all over the country. They meet every few months and highlight interesting cases to learn from them. Despite her natural reluctance, Ariella agreed to be showcased and walked onstage before all these professors to show them what progress could be made. Despite the rareness of CIDP, studies show that it is more prevalent for some reason in Israel, across all demographics, and if we could help someone else with this condition in some way, we wanted to be part of it.

It’s been a long haul since those tumultuous years. B’chasdei Hashem, Ariella is now in her twenties and has not suffered another attack. Yet she is disabled, with limited mobility and balance, often falling and suffering from those wrenching spills.

Still, she’s determined to live independently, sharing an apartment in Jerusalem where she works. Her job is accessible and attuned to her needs and it’s a huge comfort knowing she’s happy where she is and with what she’s doing. Yet she’ll always be at risk for another sudden, surprise attack.

We try not to let our worry get the better of us, and aim to focus on what is going on at the moment, appreciating every day and not worrying about the future. As a doula, I often tell my clients that while the pain of contractions can be hard, the payback is so worth it. Similarly, Ariella and our family know that the pain and difficulties that come with living with a disability are huge and often distressing. Still, we focus on the moment and the appreciation and enjoyment of each day at a time.

Please daven for Ariella Hadassa bas Leah Chasha for a refuah shleimah.

https://mishpacha.com/one-step-at-a-time-2/

 

Sweet Sophia of blessed memory

See: It is ok to think that every child matters however a lot of them do not https://www.blogger.com/blog/post/edit/2186593343917545414/8725115122337467655 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gwNQqnEYMXw

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfZU0pbgQ00

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yIbv3WxbisM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SwfVu6BKzVc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vYMX0Iq0W8E

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXO4jnDdXIw&list=RDCMUC5gtFZgs1KvVvY0_KRH9Mpw&index=2

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ItMa7dXPUnU&list=RDCMUC5gtFZgs1KvVvY0_KRH9Mpw&index=3

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DiSyk0P6bFY