Tuesday, January 16, 2018

It only hurts when I laugh

Ran Y, Liu H, Zhang M, Dong Z, Yu S. Laugh-Induced Headache: Clinical Features and Literature Review. Headache. 2017 Nov;57(10):1498-1506.

Abstract
Background. Laughing is a rare precipitating factor for headaches, and the pathogenesis underlying laugh-induced headache (LH) remains unclear.

Methods. Two cases of headache triggered predominantly by laughing were presented in this article. We also reviewed the published English literature regarding LH, summarized the clinical characteristics of LH, and discussed the probable pathophysiological mechanisms. 

Results. In the first patient, magnetic resonance imaging of the brain revealed cerebellar tonsillar herniation through the foramen magnum. In the second patient, we did not find any evidence of intracranial disease. The literature review showed that LH is a mild to severe, non-pulsating headache. In most cases, the duration of each attack was limited to a few minutes. The headache usually bursts after laughing and reaches its peak almost immediately. In some cases, the headache can only be induced by mirthful laughing rather than by fake laughing.

Conclusion. LH can be categorized as primary LH and secondary LH. Changes in the spatial structure in the posterior cranial fossa and cerebrospinal fluid circulation may contribute to the development of secondary LH. Primary LH, primary cough headache, and primary exercise headache may share some common pathogenesis. And we speculate that the regions of the brain associated with the expression of mirth might be associated with LH.
____________________________________________________________________________

From the article

A 32-year-old woman reported recurrent headaches following outbursts of laughing over a period of 3 years. The pain was intense and located in both parietal and occipital areas. Attacks lasted 10 seconds. There was no associated nausea, vomiting, photophobia, or phonophobia. She had also suffered similar headaches after bending but never after coughing, sneezing, sexual activity, or exercise. She did not previously suffer from headaches and did not have a family history of headache. The neurological examination was negative. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of her brain revealed cerebellar tonsillar herniation through the foramen magnum, also known as Arnold-Chiari malformation type 1 (CM-1);. She refused brain surgery or conventional headache medication and managed symptoms by avoiding triggering factors…

A 19-year-old man was referred to our department because of bursting with severe headache after playing basketball for 20 minutes. For over half a year, he had experienced episodic mild headache triggered by laughing, without any other triggers. The pain also reached its peak immediately and resolved within 1 minute after resting or stopping laughing. The nonthrobbing headache was felt in both occipital areas and was mild to intense without any associated symptoms. He had no history of other headaches. The neurological examination and brain MRI were normal. The patient declined any further investigation, including magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) and magnetic resonance venography. He was treated with indomethacin 25 mg twice a day for 1 month, after which he has no longer suffered any headache attack, even after laughing or any other strenuous physical exercise for the following 3 years…

Giraud et al reported a case of severe headache provoked by outbursts of laughing, and MRI discovered giant pacchionian granulations (GPGs) in bilateral transverse sinuses and the superior sagittal sinus. The patient suffered an intense, nonpulsating, whole-head headache lasting 4–5 minutes for each attack. With the exception of the patient reported by Boga, none of the other previous reports, including the first patient we reported above, underwent brain surgery on CM-1 malformation or GPG…

The course of headache in a patient reported by Levin et al[8] was divided into two stages. At first, the severe headache burst with boisterous laughing and weight lifting. In the second stage, the patient suffered recurrent bouts of excruciating headache of 10 seconds in duration, triggered by moderate mirthful laugh. Interestingly, "fake" laughing (the absence of a mirthful feeling) did not produce any pain. Nonsteroid anti-inflammatory drugs were not able to prevent the patient's headaches. Nevertheless, divalproex sodium had significant preventive effects…

With headache characteristics that differed from those of other cases, each attack of Shatti's patient lasted for most of the day and had accompanying symptoms, including kaleidoscopic visual disturbance, photophobia, and nausea. After the patient was treated with nortriptyline, the frequency of headache attacks decreased significantly.

LH was a mild to severe, nonpulsating headache. In most cases, the duration of the headache attack was limited to a few minutes. The headache attack usually bursts with laughing and reaches its peak immediately. In some cases, with unremarkable MRI findings, headaches were mainly induced by mirthful laughing, rather than by fake laughing, and had good responses to acute or prophylactic drugs for primary headache…

All these types of headache [laugh headaches, primary cough headache, primary exercise headache] begin immediately or within seconds after being triggered, reach their peak immediately, and last for a few minutes. Although most cases of PEH are pulsating, LH and PCH are both nonthrobbing. Attacks predominantly affect bilateral and posterior areas of the head in patients with PCH or primary LH.  The primary headache may have associated symptoms and responds well to indomethacin…

The pathogeny of LH has been reported to include CM-1, GPG, thrombophlebitis, intracranial tumors, posterior arachnoid cysts, intracranial hypotension, and unruptured posterior communicating artery aneurysm.   All types of etiologies have influence on the spatial structure of the posterior cranial fossa and cerebrospinal fluid circulation…

In addition, the similarity of good responses in primary LH, PCH, and PEH to indomethacin or prophylactic drugs for treating primary headache compels us to consider that there may be more common pathologies underlying these primary headaches…

In reports by Levin et al and Shatti et al, patients suffered with headache mainly after mirthful laughing. This is not a unique instance about headache in connection with emotional change. As Blau in 1995 and Evans in 1998 both reported, patients with migraine-like headaches that were precipitated by crying were associated with sadness or emotional upset. However, the headaches could not be triggered by crying from happiness or cutting onions…

Therefore, we speculate that the regions of the brain associated with the expression of mirth might be associated with LH.  The exact pathophysiological connection between emotional laughing and LH requires further study.

LH can be categorized as primary LH and secondary LH. Neurological analysis and imaging examination are necessary to exclude secondary cases in patients with similar symptoms. The first patient we reported with CM-1 can be categorized as secondary LH, while the second patient can be categorized as primary LH. We concluded that changes in spatial structure in the posterior cranial fossa and cerebrospinal fluid circulation may contribute to the development of secondary LH. For primary LH, there may be some common pathologies underlying primary headaches, including primary LH, PCH, and PEH. Considering that in some patients, primary LH is only triggered by mirthful laugh, we speculate that the regions of the brain associated with the expression of mirth might be associated with LH.

No comments:

Post a Comment