In December, 2015, the Migration Board rejected their final
appeal, and, in a letter, told the family, “You must leave Sweden.” Their
deportation to Russia was scheduled for April. Soslan said that to his children
Russia “might as well be the moon.” Georgi read the letter silently, dropped it
on the floor, went upstairs to his room, and lay down on the bed. He said that
his body began to feel as if it were entirely liquid. His limbs felt soft and
porous. All he wanted to do was close his eyes. Even swallowing required an
effort that he didn’t feel he could muster. He felt a deep pressure in his
brain and in his ears. He turned toward the wall and pounded his fist against
it. In the morning, he refused to get out of bed or to eat. Savl poured
Coca-Cola into a teaspoon and fed Georgi small sips. The soda dribbled down his
chin.
At the recommendation of neighbors, Georgi’s parents called
Elisabeth Hultcrantz, an ear-nose-and-throat doctor who volunteers for the
charity Doctors of the World. Three days after Georgi took to his bed,
Hultcrantz drove to his home, a red wooden cottage with white trim in the
farmlands of Garpenberg, a hundred and twenty miles northwest of Stockholm.
Georgi was wearing boxers and short athletic socks. He appeared to be asleep. A
tulip-patterned blanket had been pulled up to his chin. When Hultcrantz touched
him, his eyelids trembled, but he didn’t move. Using a pillow, she propped up
his head, but it flopped to the side. “He provides no contact whatsoever,” she
wrote.
After a week, Georgi had lost thirteen pounds. Hultcrantz, a
professor emeritus at Linköping University, urged the family to take him to the
emergency room in Falun, a city forty miles away. He hadn’t eaten for four days
and had not spoken a full sentence in a week.
A doctor at the hospital wrote that Georgi “lies completely
still on the examination table.” His reflexes were intact and his pulse and
blood pressure were normal. The doctor lifted Georgi’s wrists a few inches
above his forehead and then dropped them. “They fall down on his face,” she
wrote. A nurse noted that he showed “no reaction to caregiving.”
The next day, a doctor inserted a feeding tube through
Georgi’s nostril. “He showed no resistance,” Soslan said. “Nothing.” Georgi was
given a diagnosis of uppgivenhetssyndrom, or resignation syndrome, an illness
that is said to exist only in Sweden, and only among refugees. The patients
have no underlying physical or neurological disease, but they seem to have lost
the will to live. The Swedish refer to them as de apatiska, the apathetic. “I
think it is a form of protection, this coma they are in,” Hultcrantz said.
“They are like Snow White. They just fall away from the world.”
The apathetic children began showing up in Swedish emergency
rooms in the early two-thousands. Their parents were convinced that they were
dying. Of what, they didn’t know; they worried about cholera or some unknown
plague. Soon patients with the condition filled all the beds in Stockholm’s
only psychiatric inpatient unit for children, at Karolinska University
Hospital. Göran Bodegård, the director of the unit, told me that he felt
claustrophobic when he entered the rooms. “An atmosphere of Michelangelo’s
‘Pietà’ lingered around the child,” he said. The blinds were drawn, and the
lights were off. The mothers whispered, rarely spoke to their sick children,
and stared into the darkness.
By 2005, more than four hundred children, most between the
ages of eight and fifteen, had fallen into the condition. In the medical
journal Acta Pædiatrica, Bodegård described the typical patient as “totally
passive, immobile, lacks tonus, withdrawn, mute, unable to eat and drink,
incontinent and not reacting to physical stimuli or pain.” Nearly all the
children had emigrated from former Soviet and Yugoslav states, and a
disproportionate number were Roma or Uyghur. Sweden has been a haven for
refugees since the seventies, accepting more asylum seekers per capita than any
other European nation, but the country’s definition of political refugees had
recently narrowed. Families fleeing countries that were not at war were often
denied asylum…
In a hundred-and-thirty-page report on the condition,
commissioned by the government and published in 2006, a team of psychologists,
political scientists, and sociologists hypothesized that it was a culture-bound
syndrome, a psychological illness endemic to a specific society. Every culture
possesses what Edward Shorter, a medical historian at the University of
Toronto, calls a “ ‘symptom repertoire’—a range of physical symptoms available
to the unconscious mind for the physical expression of psychological conflict.”…
Georgi spent three nights at the hospital in Falun before
being sent home with a special supportive mattress. His friends called and
texted him repeatedly, but they received no response. Georgi’s teachers called
his family to find out why he had been absent for a week. Floridan, the
headmaster, said that Georgi’s classmates were in tears when he explained what
had happened. He told them, “Georgi has waited such a long time to get an
answer about whether he can stay here in Sweden, and he has more or less given
up. He finds no meaning in school or to even exist.”
A physiotherapist at the hospital advised Georgi’s parents
to turn on the lights in his bedroom every morning, and to immerse him in the
daily routine of the household. Georgi was rolled to the dinner table in a
wheelchair; a cushioned headrest propped up his head, though his eyes remained
closed. He was fed four hundred and fifty millilitres of nutrients five times a
day, through a tube…
In a seventy-six-page guide for treating
uppgivenhetssyndrom, published in 2013, the Swedish Board of Health and Welfare
advises that a patient will not recover until his family has permission to live
in Sweden. “A permanent residency permit is considered by far the most
effective ‘treatment,’ ” the manual says. “The turning point will usually be a
few months to half a year after the family receives permanent residence.”…
A chipper, gray-haired grandmother, Hultcrantz seems unaware
of her power. She sometimes encourages families to “get their tubing”—the
feeding tube—as quickly as possible, in order to emphasize their suffering to
the Migration Board. Her iPhone is full of photographs that she has taken of
refugee children lying in bed. Their eyes are closed, their faces are pale, and
they have an expression of dull tranquillity…
In April, four months after Georgi became ill, the family’s
deportation was postponed, because his dependence on the feeding tube made
flying hazardous. He seemed to be sinking deeper into the condition. Hultcrantz
observed that he had begun to drool. At Falun Hospital, a doctor noted that
Georgi had “no muscle tone in either the arms or legs,” and that his arm
reflexes were “difficult to trigger.” The doctor wrote, “The boy is alive but
barely.”…
No apathetic patients are known to have died, but a few have
been bedridden for as long as four years…
In late May, 2016, Georgi’s family received another letter
from the Migration Board. Their neighbor Ellina Zapolskaia translated it. “The
Migration Board finds no reason to question what is stated about Georgi’s
health,” she read out loud. “He is therefore considered to be in need of a safe
and stable environment and living conditions in order to recuperate.” The
family was granted permanent residence in Sweden.
Georgi’s parents immediately went upstairs to his bedroom to
tell him. He showed no reaction. “He doesn’t listen,” Zapolskaia said. “He’s
not there—not anywhere.” For two weeks, Georgi’s brother, parents, and friends
tried to get him to absorb the good news. His family took him in his wheelchair
to an ice-skating rink, where his classmates were playing hockey, but the fresh
air had little noticeable effect. “You have got the positive!” one of his
friends kept shouting. Zapolskaia said, “We tried to show him that our mood had
changed.”…
On June 6th, two weeks after the family learned that they
could stay in Sweden, Georgi opened his eyes. “It was just a little—a little,”
Zapolskaia said. He quickly shut them. “The light was too painful,” Georgi said
later. “But I remember that I saw my family.” His body throbbed, as if he had
just exercised far beyond his natural capacity…
Like most apathetic children, Georgi regained physical
abilities in the reverse order in which he had lost them. He opened his eyes;
made eye contact with his family; began to feed himself; started to walk,
shakily at first and then more steadily; and finally began to talk in full
sentences…
“All my will—I didn’t
have it anymore,” he said. “It felt like I was deep under water.” He struggled
to find language that could adequately capture the experience. “I was just very
tired,” he said at one point. “It was not like now—I want to go and run.” At
another point, he compared it to eating too much: “You don’t have any
appetite.” He didn’t seem satisfied with either description and tried again:
“My whole body was like water.”
http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/04/03/the-trauma-of-facing-deportation
Courtesy of a colleague
Bodegård G. Pervasive loss of function in asylum-seeking children in Sweden. Acta Paediatr. 2005 Dec;94(12):1706-7.
ReplyDeleteAbstract
Presently, a couple of hundred children from traumatized asylum-seeking families in Sweden have developed severe loss of mental and physical functions without evidence of underlying disease. Of the 23 treated children treated at this clinic, 15 have recovered, three are improving and five are under initial care. Communication within the family is crucial from both pathogenic and salutogenic perspectives. A permanent residence permit, correcting the underlying situation of threat and insecurity, is a condition for good results from psychiatric treatment. In Sweden there is a lack of consensus and conflicting political and medical perspectives prevail regarding the "apathetic" children.
CONCLUSION:
Children living under unbearable life conditions can develop life-threatening depression-withdrawal stress reactions well known as pervasive refusal syndrome (PRS). This is also true of children in traumatized asylum-seeking families. Excellent results are achieved when the family's underlying fear and hopelessness can be erased and the treatment focuses on the traumatic experiences.
Forslund CM, Johansson BA. Pervasive refusal syndrome among inpatient asylum-seeking children and adolescents: a follow-up study. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2013 Apr;22(4):251-8.
ReplyDeleteAbstract
BACKGROUND:
Pervasive refusal syndrome (PRS) is a rare but severe condition, characterised by social withdrawal and a pervasive active refusal in terms of eating, mobilisation, speech and personal hygiene. PRS has been proposed as a new diagnostic entity in child and adolescent psychiatry, although the diagnostic criteria are debated. In the past 10 years there has been an increase in PRS symptoms among asylum-seeking children and adolescents in Sweden. Here, we describe five cases of PRS among asylum-seeking children and adolescents.
METHOD:
Three females and 2 males, 7-17 years of age with the clinical picture of PRS, treated as inpatients at the Department of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Malmö, Sweden, 2002-2010, were analysed on the basis of their medical records. Subjects were diagnosed using previously suggested criteria for PRS. At follow-up, a semi-structured interview focusing on the inpatient stay and current status was performed. The subjects were assessed with Global Assessment of Functioning (GAF) and self-rating questionnaires regarding depression and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
RESULTS:
The pattern of refusal varied among the five subjects. All subjects originated from former Soviet republics, indicating a possible cultural factor. Mean period of inpatient treatment was 5 months. All subjects received intense nursing and were treated with nasogastric tube feeding. Parents were involved and were given support and instructions. All subjects gradually improved after receiving permanent residency permits. Depression and PTSD were co-morbid states. At follow-up, 1-8 years after discharge, all subjects were recovered.
CONCLUSION:
Although a severe condition, our five cases suggest a good prognosis for PRS among asylum-seeking children and adolescents.