People who have suffered a traumatic brain injury are approximately 2.5 times more likely to be incarcerated in a federal correctional facility in Canada than people who have not, a new study has found.
“These findings contribute to emerging research suggesting traumatic brain injury is an important risk factor for involvement with the criminal justice system,” said lead author Dr. Flora Matheson of the Centre for Urban Health Solutions of St. Michael’s Hospital and an adjunct scientist at the Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences.
“This may be just the tip of the iceberg as our study focused only on people with more serious TBI,” she said. “We also did not include people who may have served time in provincial, rather than federal jails.” The study was published online in the journal CMAJ Open.
The authors stressed that the overall risk of someone who has experienced TBI being incarcerated was still low, at less than five in 1,000, compared to less than two in 1,000 for people without a history of TBI. However, knowing that people who are incarcerated are much more likely to have experienced brain injury than the general population will help health–care providers better identify people at risk for incarceration and provide better care for people within the prison system.
The researchers identified nearly 1.42 million adults ages 18–28 who were eligible for health care in Ontario on July 1, 1997, and followed them to the end of 2011. The age group was selected because of its high risk of TBI and involvement in the criminal justice system.
Their health information, including previous TBIs, was obtained from emergency and hospital records stored at ICES, and linked to incarceration records held by the Correctional Service of Canada.
Of the 77,519 people with a history of TBI, 402 were incarcerated during the 14– year period, a rate of 0.5 per cent. This was more than double the rate of people with no history of TBI (3,331 people out of 1,401,887, or 0.2 per cent).
To examine the impact of the issue more clearly, Dr. Matheson and her team further broke down the numbers to look at the rate of incarceration, taking into account the number of new cases and years spent incarcerated for each group during the study period.
The researchers found incarceration was 2.47 times higher in men who had sustained a TBI before being incarcerated in a federal correctional facility compared to men who had not.
For women, incarceration was 2.76 times higher for those who had suffered a TBI in comparison to women who did not suffer a TBI. However, the researchers did note that the number of incarcerated women with TBI was small – 17 of 210 incarcerated women.
Dr. Matheson, a medical sociologist, said that while her study found an association between TBI and incarceration, rather than evidence that TBIs caused people to be incarcerated, it highlighted the fact that many people are being incarcerated with a potentially serious health issue.
Dr. Matheson said this study was one of the largest of its kind, with 16 per cent more criminal justice events than reported previously, and was the first Canadian study to explore how TBI is associated with serious or chronic offending among people in federal custody. Another novel aspect was that the findings applied similarly to men and women, although she noted the number of women studied was small.
Kathryn E. McIsaac, Andrea Moser, Rahim Moineddin, Leslie Anne Keown, Geoff Wilton, Lynn A. Stewart, Angela Colantonio, Avery B. Nathens, Flora I. Matheson. Association between traumatic brain injury and incarceration: a population-based cohort study. CMAJ Open. http://cmajopen.ca/content/4/4/E746.full
Background: There is recent evidence to suggest that sustaining a traumatic brain injury (TBI) increases risk of criminal justice system involvement, including incarceration. The objective of this study was to explore the association between TBI and risk of incarceration among men and women in Ontario.
Methods: We identified a cohort of 1.418 million young adults (aged 18-28 yr) on July 1, 1997, living in Ontario, Canada, from administrative health records; they were followed to Dec. 31, 2011. History of TBI was obtained from emergency and hospital records, and incarceration history was obtained from the Correctional Service of Canada records. We estimated the hazard of incarceration using Cox proportional hazard models, adjusting for relevant sociodemographic characteristics and medical history.
Results: There were 3531 incarcerations over 18 297 508 person-years of follow-up. The incidence of incarceration was higher among participants with prior TBI compared with those without a prior TBI. In fully adjusted models, men and women who had sustained a TBI were about 2.5 times more likely to be incarcerated than men and women who had not sustained a TBI.
Interpretation: Traumatic brain injury was associated with an increased risk of incarceration among men and women in Ontario. Our research highlights the importance of designing primary, secondary and tertiary prevention strategies to mitigate risk of TBI and incarceration in the population.
Post a Comment